Methodological advantages and disadvantages of parallel. The use of metaanalysis to formally combine results from several clinical trials is growing rapidly. At the same time there have been great strides in the development and refinement of the associated statistical. Findings in a meta analysis of 87 randomized clinical trials 17 540 unique participants on the use of antidepressants in individuals with major depression, there was 14% more variability in response to antidepressants than to placebo. In 2011, we published a metaanalysis of randomised clinical trials examining the effect of exercise on depressive symptoms in patients with clinical depression. In practice, this implies the combination of the results of several individual clinical trials using specialized statistical methodology. At the same time there have been great strides in the development and refinement of the associated statistical methodology. Randomized clinical trials on the effects of current volatile anesthetics. The structure of study records in xml is defined by this xml schema. Effect of dose and duration of reduction in dietary sodium.
Meta analysis included 14 of the 28 studies n 20,897 that measured the proportion of children who consumed whole milk compared with reducedfat milk and direct. Setting and participants we searched relevant databases up to march 2015 and included data. Dec 15, 2014 the aim of this study was to examine whether albumin reduced mortality when employed for the resuscitation of adult patients with severe sepsis and septic shock compared with crystalloid by meta analysis. Meta analysis in clinical trials 181 where 0i is the true treatment effect in the ith study, w is the mean effect for a population of possible treatment evaluations, and 8i is the deviation of the ith studys effect from the population mean. Pdf metaanalysis of randomised clinical trials comparing. Overall, the trials included 3140 patients from australia, england, india. Individual differences in response to antidepressants. This file was read into stata using wbdecode and the metaanalysis was plotted using the stata command meta in figure 1.
Jan 18, 2014 the only previous meta analysis of the effects of fenugreek on glycemia included only two clinical trials as compared with 10 in the current meta analysis. This has mainly been due to greater emphasis on evidencebased medicine and the need for reliable summaries of the vast and expanding volume of clinical research. Metaanalysis in clinical trials revisited sciencedirect. Our new yale medicineyale new haven health covid19 call center offers information on how to keep yourself and your family healthy. Mar 23, 2016 meta analyses of the effect of important food sources of sugars on cardiometabolic risk factors the safety and scientific validity of this study is the responsibility of the study sponsor and investigators. These were copied and pasted into the text file data. In contrast, our study included a more powerful method network metaanalysis. Pioglitazone and the secondary prevention of cardiovascular. This is a pdf file of an unedited manuscript that has. Volatile anesthetics versus propofol for cardiac surgery.
The historical roots of metaanalysis can be traced back to 17th century studies of astronomy, while a paper published in 1904 by the statistician karl pearson in the british medical journal which collated data from several studies of typhoid inoculation is seen as the first time a metaanalytic approach was used to aggregate the outcomes of multiple clinical studies. Jul 15, 2019 the challenge posed by prs in clinical trials is not the magnitude of the pr but rather the magnitude of the pr relative to the treatment effect. Data from 28 active treatment arms or strata from 22 randomized clinical trials were pooled using a weighted average method, with weights proportional to the inverse of the variance of the treatment effect. Such analyses are becoming increasingly popular in medical research where information on efficacy of a treatment is available from a number of clinical studies. Electronic and nonelectronic searches were conducted to identify relevant human. Metaanalysis did not begin to appear regularly in the medical literature until the late 1970s but since then a plethora of metaanalyses have emerged and the growth is exponential over time figure 2 3. We need a better understanding of the validity of their results to enable recommendations as to which crossover trials can be included in metaanalysis and for development of reporting. Metaanalyses of the effect of important food sources of sugars on cardiometabolic risk factors the safety and scientific validity of this study is the. For metaanalysis in clinical trials 1, we adopted this same. As a secondary analysis, we compared the findings of the three vitamin c and e trials with our meta regression model based on the eight trials using vitamin c alone fig.
Metaanalysis is the quantitative analysis of the results included in an sr. Current curative therapies are expensive, challenging to access and have significant risks, making them infeasible and. The quality of included studies was assessed using the cochrane collaboration risk of bias rob assessment tool. For instance, a metaanalysis may be conducted on several clinical trials of a medical. Data sources ovid medliner, embase, and cochrane central register of controlled trials wiley and reference lists of relevant articles up to 21 january 2019. Analysis of controlled clinical trials wiley online. Methods inclusion criteria the inclusion criteria were. Metaanalysis of clinical trials in schizophrenia human laboratory study of menthols effects on nicotine reinforcement in smokers fmri study of working memory in schizophrenia. Oct 16, 2017 pioglitazone targets multiple pathogenic pathways involved in the development of cardiovascular diseases cvd. Save as unformatted text that can be read in a simple editor, such as notepad. As a secondary analysis, we compared the findings of the three vitamin c and e trials with our metaregression model based on the eight trials using vitamin c alone fig. Effect of probiotic supplementation in pregnant women. Results of included trials, seven examined the effect of eating breakfast on weight change, and 10 examined the effect on energy intake. Metaanalysis of trials provides a precise estimate of.
Randomizedcontrolled trials of pioglitazone in patients with cvd were identified through pubmed, embase, cochrane and cinahl, in. Strengths of our study included the comprehensive literature search leading to the identification of a reasonably large number of trials and a detailed analysis of potential sources of. One such slimming aid is the bean extract, phaseolus vulgaris. Crossdesign synthesisa new form of metaanalysis for combining results from randomized clinical trials and medicalpractice databases. Like any other research process, a number of steps are required see table 1. Effect of procalcitoninguided antibiotic treatment on. Application of metaanalysis in clinical trials, continued 2 1 each study effect size the first step in metaanalysis calculation is to get the effect size estimation for each study. This test determines how many negative studies with an effect size of d 0. Findings in a metaanalysis of 87 randomized clinical trials 17 540 unique participants on the use of antidepressants in individuals with major depression, there was 14% more variability in response to antidepressants than to placebo. A previously reported metaanalysis of 8 trials in 2014 examined continuous vs intermittent chemotherapy strategies for patients with mcrc. Inclusion criteria randomised trials comparing different levels of sodium intake undertaken among adult populations. Aromatherapy was effective in reducing the identified. The efficacy of phaseolus vulgaris as a weightloss supplement.
Metaanalysis of controlled clinical trials statistics in practice. Dietary calcium and blood pressurea metaanalysis of. This book describes the planning, conduct and reporting of a meta analysis as applied to a series of randomized controlled clinical trials. Metaanalysis allows the researcher to reach conclusions based on a set of independently performed studies. This patientlevel metaanalysis based on 11 randomized trials investigates the impact of procalcitoninguided antibiotic therapy on mortality in intensive care unit icu patients with infection, both overall and stratified according to sepsis definition. Comparative efficacy of statins, metformin, spironolactone. Baseline severity of depression did not moderate this variability, but variability in response to. Package clinfun has functions for both design and analysis of clinical trials. Cohens d, hedges g, and glass delta using formulas below.
We searched five electronic databases till november 15th 20 including those chinese and english language articles. Meta analysis is the quantitative analysis of the results included in an sr. Our meta analysis of clinical trials showed that nut consumption was associated with a nonsignificant decrease in body weight of 0. The various approaches are presented within a general unified framework. The efficacy of phaseolus vulgaris as a weightloss. A variety of dietary supplements are presently available as slimming aids, but their efficacy has not been proven. Analysis of controlled clinical trials wiley online books. Methods we conducted an individual participant data metaanalysis of three randomised clinical trials that compared a strategy using a polypill containing aspirin, statin and antihypertensive therapy with usual care in patients with a prior cardiovascular disease cvd event or who were at high risk of their first event. Efficacy of multicomponent treatment in fibromyalgia.
The historical roots of meta analysis can be traced back to 17th century studies of astronomy, while a paper published in 1904 by the statistician karl pearson in the british medical journal which collated data from several studies of typhoid inoculation is seen as the first time a meta analytic approach was used to aggregate the outcomes of multiple clinical studies. Randomized crossover trials are clinical experiments in which participants are assigned randomly to a sequence of treatments and each participant serves as hisher own control in estimating treatment effect. As such, a metaanalysis uses a similar rigorous methodology as is required of experimental research studies decoster, 2009. Almost all of these were in social sciences with 50% in psychology, 32% in education research and 10% in business economics. The role of maintenance strategies in metastatic colorectal. Such analyses are essentially observational, using trials as the unit of enrollment rather than individual patients. The metaanalysis data are given in the winbugs manual in the form of r style lists. Design, analysis, and reporting of crossover trials for. Objective to assess the methodological advantages and disadvantages of parallel and crossover designs in randomised clinical trials on methylphenidate for children and adolescents with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder adhd. Osteoarthritis oa is a major global burden creating significant morbidity worldwide. Reaching cardiovascular prevention guideline targets with. Studies were eligible if they compared the effects of. Metaanalysis techniques are described in detail, from their theoretical development through to practical implementation.
In 18 studies, higher cowmilk fat consumption was associated with lower child adiposity, and 10 studies did not identify an association. Metaanalysis is defined here as the statistical analysis of a collection of analytic results for the purpose of integrating the findings. Over the last twenty years there has been a dramatic upsurge in the application of meta analysis to medical research. This document, when finalized, will provide guidance. To answer this question we performed this meta analysis of randomized clinical trials rct analysing the short, medium and longterms effects of insulin on clinical outcomes in t2d. Following the introduction of the term meta analysis in 1976 and before the publication of our article, meta analysis in clinical trials, in 1986, web of science lists 222 articles with the term meta analysis in the title. In 2011, we published a meta analysis of randomised clinical trials examining the effect of exercise on depressive symptoms in patients with clinical depression. Health professionals are available to answer your questions, monday friday, 7 am 7 pm. A previous metaanalysis of oa trials showed a rise in the pr of the placebo group in proportion to the es of the active treatment, an effect known as the placebo analgesia theory. Metaanalysis in clinical trials 181 where 0i is the true treatment effect in the ith study, w is the mean effect for a population of possible treatment evaluations, and 8i is the deviation of the ith studys effect from the population mean. Comparative safety and effectiveness of cholinesterase. This document, when finalized, will provide guidance to applicants submitting investigational new drug applications, new drug applications, biologics license applications, or supplemental applications on the use of meta analyses of randomized controlled clinical trials rcts to evaluate the safety of human drugs or biological products within. Hence it is different from metaanalysis of clinical trials with sparse events where trial sizes are small often for reasons of patient recruitment but event probabilities might not necessarily be small. The hull york medical school, hertford building, university of hull, hu6 7rx, nuffield department of orthopaedics, rheumatology and musculoskeletal sciences, university of oxford.
Interpret the results of a meta analysis including forest plots become familiar with the grade approach and its use in creating clinical practice guidelines and implementing evidence. A comparison of fixed and random effects approaches is included, as well as a discussion of bayesian methods and cumulative metaanalysis. Metaanalysis of the results found a small difference in weight favouring. Metaanalysis included 14 of the 28 studies n 20,897 that measured the proportion of children who consumed whole milk compared with reducedfat milk and direct. The aim of this study was to examine whether albumin reduced mortality when employed for the resuscitation of adult patients with severe sepsis and septic shock compared with crystalloid by metaanalysis.
The merits and perils of the somewhat mysterious procedure of metaanalysis, however. Our metaanalysis of clinical trials showed that nut consumption was associated with a nonsignificant decrease in body weight of 0. Metaanalyses of randomized controlled clinical trials to evaluate the safety of human drugs or biological products guidance for industry. A metaanalysis is a statistical analysis that combines the results of multiple scientific studies. Randomizedcontrolled trials of pioglitazone in patients with cvd were identified through pubmed, embase, cochrane and cinahl, in a search up to. Metaanalyses of the effect of important food sources of. To answer this question we performed this metaanalysis of randomized clinical trials rct analysing the short, medium and longterms effects of insulin on clinical outcomes in t2d. Metaanalysis is most often used to assess the clinical. Although the magnitude of these effects was modest, the results allay the fear that nut consumption may promote obesity. This book describes the planning, conduct and reporting of a metaanalysis as applied to a series of randomized controlled clinical trials. The basic idea of the approach is the same, but here we assumed the treatment effect for the ith study, y i. The only previous metaanalysis of the effects of fenugreek on glycemia included only two clinical trials as compared with 10 in the current metaanalysis. Such analyses are becoming increasingly popular in medical research where information on efficacy of a treatment is available from a number of clinical studies with similar treatment protocols.
A previously reported meta analysis of 8 trials in 2014 examined continuous vs intermittent chemotherapy strategies for patients with mcrc. For assessment of cognition, all drugs except for rivastigmine 5cm 2 patch were significantly more efficacious than placebo for mild to moderate ad. In a metaanalysis of data from 23 studies evaluating the effect of coaching on sat. Metaanalysis of pain and function placebo responses in. Metaanalysis in clinical research annals of internal. For phase ii trials, it has functions to calculate sample size, effect size, and power based on fishers exact test, the operating characteristics of a twostage boundary, optimal and minimax 2stage phase ii designs given by richard simon, the exact 1stage phase ii. Metaanalyses of randomized controlled clinical trials to. The benefits of metaanalysis include a consolidated and quantitative. Save each study as a separate line in the file, with tabs as delimiters, or spacers, between each field. International journal of technology assessment in health care 9 3, 440449. Pdf metaanalysis of randomized trials on first line and.
Data from 28 active treatment arms or strata from 22 randomized clinical trials were pooled using a weighted average method, with weights proportional to the inverse of the variance of the. We searched for and gathered data from medline, elsevier, cochrane central register of controlled trials and web of science databases. For metaanalysis in clinical trials, we adopted this same randomeffects approach to integrate the findings from a number of related clinical trials to strengthen the evidence for the efficacy of a certain treatment for a specified medical condition. The challenge posed by prs in clinical trials is not the magnitude of the pr but rather the magnitude of the pr relative to the treatment effect.
She wonders if thyroid replacement will help with her. Detailed results of pairwise metaanalyses are presented in additional file 1. Save as portable document format pdf, a standard format accessible using the freely available adobe acrobat reader dc. Calculation of effect size between two means can be done by three measures.
Furthermore, we tested the sensitivity of our results to potential unpublished studies using a file. Efficacy of multicomponent treatment in fibromyalgia syndrome. It explains how to download study record data in extensible markup language xml, a machinereadable format, and in other data formats. Each topic discussed is supported by detailed worked examples. Vitamin c may reduce the duration of mechanical ventilation. Meta analysis of randomized clinical trials is not an infallible tool, however, and several examples exist of meta analyses which were later contradicted by single large randomized controlled trials, and of meta analyses addressing the same issue which have reached opposite conclusions 72. A meta analysis of randomized controlled trials research to rank the trials in terms of their study design and methodological quality, and assessed the reported benefits of the same probiotic strains on anxiety. Over the last twenty years there has been a dramatic upsurge in the application of metaanalysis to medical research. The clinical utility of serum procalcitonin levels in guiding antibiotic treatment decisions in patients with sepsis remains unclear. The examination of variability or heterogeneity in study results is also a critical outcome. In contrast, our study included a more powerful method network meta analysis. Archived from the original pdf on 22 november 2011. Effect of dose and duration of reduction in dietary sodium on. Moreover, it has been shown that metaanalyses are the most frequently cited form of clinical research 4.
1242 1283 400 729 642 129 984 1434 1027 774 382 17 90 41 379 343 316 415 914 371 1210 1447 1240 344 382 125 1506 1375 102 128 189 379 1331 672 196 938 541 437 1489 919 1473 462 121 1286 304 1233